Understanding the nineteenth century origins of disciplines: lessons for astrobiology today?
نویسندگان
چکیده
Astrobiology’s goal of promoting interdisciplinary research is an attempt to reverse a trend that began two centuries ago with the formation of the first specialized scientific disciplines. We have examined this era of discipline formation in order to make a comparison with the situation today in astrobiology. Will astrobiology remain interdisciplinary or is it becoming yet another specialty? As a case study, we have investigated effects on the scientific literature when a specialized community is formed by analyzing the citations within papers published during 1802–1856 in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (Phil. Trans.), the most important ‘generalist ’ journal of its day, and Transactions of the Geological Society of London (Trans. Geol. Soc.), the first important disciplinary journal in the sciences. We find that these two journals rarely cited each other, and papers published in Trans. Geol. Soc. cited fewer interdisciplinary sources than did geology papers in Phil. Trans. After geology had become established as a successful specialized discipline, geologists returned to publishing papers in Phil. Trans., but they wrote in the new, highly specialized style developed in Trans. Geol. Soc. They had succeeded in not only creating a new scientific discipline, but also a new way of doing science with its own modes of research and communication. A similar citation analysis was applied to papers published over the period 2001–2008 in the contemporary journals Astrobiology and the International Journal of Astrobiology to test the hypothesis that astrobiologists are in the early stages of creating their own specialized community. Although still too early to reliably detect any but the largest trends, there is no evidence yet that astrobiologists are drifting into their own isolated discipline. Instead, to date they appear to remain interdisciplinary. Received 8 June 2009, accepted 21 July 2009, first published online 26 August 2009
منابع مشابه
Achieving Universal Health Coverage by Focusing on Primary Care in Japan: Lessons for Low- and Middle-Income Countries
When the Japanese government adopted Western medicine in the late nineteenth century, it left intact the infrastructure of primary care by giving licenses to the existing practitioners and by initially setting the hurdle for entry into medical school low. Public financing of hospitals was kept minimal so that almost all of their revenue came from patient charges. When social health insurance (S...
متن کاملتغییر مفهوم درد طیِّ زمان
Until the mid-twentieth century, it was thought that complaint of pain has physical or psychological origins. From this time onwards, a large number of researches analyzed the correctness of pain concept and gradually changed the concept of pain. Today, according to theoretical and research resources, regardless of its type, duration and severity, pain is conceptualized as a bio-psychosocial ph...
متن کاملOrigins of epidemiology.
In this paper we trace the history of epidemiology from 1800 to the present time. The history is highly selective because our purpose is to illuminate the evolving relationship of epidemiology with demography. We first describe the common "prehistory" of these two disciplines in the early nineteenth century, and then describe their divergence during three successive eras of epidemiology up to t...
متن کاملA Comparative Study of the Historical Origins of the Emergence of the Tafkik and Akhbari Schools
The present paper is a comparative study of the historical origins of the emergence of the two Tafkik (Khorasan School of Gnostic Knowledge) and Akhbari schools. This paper is a prerequisite and an introduction to a simultaneous examination of the principles of Quranic interpretation in these two schools. In recent years, some research papers have named the Tafkik School a neo-Akhbari school an...
متن کاملIs molecular epidemiology a germ theory for the end of the twentieth century?
A recent article in this journal by Vandenbroucke drew a parallel between the possible intellectual fate of some current ideas in epidemiology and the last century's miasma theory of epidemics. Like some nineteenth century investigators, many contemporary epidemiologists are indeed guided by the principle that the origins of disease are environmental in a very broad sense. This is sometimes cal...
متن کامل